You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to user@olingo.apache.org by Peter Lawrence <pe...@inova8.com> on 2014/11/25 05:25:19 UTC
Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than EdmSimpleTypeKind
Question 1: Is my interpretation correct that Olingo2 only supports
EdmSimpleTypeKind of parameters for FunctionImports?
For example i want to declare the following
<FunctionImport Name="createRDFSClass" ReturnType="rdfs.Class"
EntitySet="rdfs_Class" >
<Parameter Name="class" Type=*"rdfs.Class"* Nullable="false"/>
<Parameter Name="label" Type="Edm.String" Nullable="true"/>
</FunctionImport>
Question 2: It also appears that Olingo4 does support parameters of type
other than EdmSimpleType. Is that correct?
Question 3: When do you anticipate releasing Olingo4, and have you any
suggestions regarding migration of an Olingo2 provider?
Many thanks
*Peter J. Lawrence*
*inova8*
*Providing answers for users' information questions*
*Mobile:* +1 330 631 3772 | *Phone:* +1 330 342 0582 | *UK Cell*:+44 795
563 2824 |*Skype:* PeterJLawrence
*Email:* peter.lawrence@inova8.com | *Web:* www.inova8.com
*LinkedIn: **http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence
<http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence>*
RE: Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than
EdmSimpleTypeKind
Posted by "Amend, Christian" <ch...@sap.com>.
Hi Peter,
yes with Olingo2 we only support the V2 specification.
Best Regards,
Christian
From: Peter Lawrence [mailto:peter.lawrence@inova8.com]
Sent: Dienstag, 25. November 2014 15:00
To: user@olingo.apache.org
Subject: Re: Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than EdmSimpleTypeKind
Thanks for your response.
With regard to Question 1, V3 suggests support for EntityType parameters (but not complex types). In which case one can compose a request such as:
.../rdfs_Class(2)/createRDFSClass(label='abc')
where the entityType parameter is bindable as specified in the edm:
<FunctionImport Name="createRDFSClass" ReturnType="rdfs.Class" EntitySet="rdfs_Class" IsBindable="true" IsSideEffecting="true" >
<Parameter Name="class" Type="rdfs.Class" Nullable="false"/>
<Parameter Name="label" Type="Edm.String" Nullable="true"/>
</FunctionImport>
Is this possible in olingo2 (the clue to my answer maybe in the fact that Olingo2 is OData2!)
Many thanks for your help and your work on Olingo
Peter
Peter J. Lawrence
inova8
Providing answers for users' information questions
Mobile: +1 330 631 3772 | Phone: +1 330 342 0582 | UK Cell:+44 795 563 2824 |Skype: PeterJLawrence
Email: peter.lawrence@inova8.com<ma...@inova8.com> | Web: www.inova8.com<http://www.inova8.com>
LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence
On Tue, Nov 25, 2014 at 7:59 AM, Amend, Christian <ch...@sap.com>> wrote:
Hi,
1. Yes we only support simple types for function import paramters since there is no specified way in V2 on how to transport a complex type via the URI.
2. Yes in V4 there is a specified way in which complex structures have to be written in the URI so we will support this in our V4 implementation.
3. There is no concrete day I could tell you. We hope to have a feature set by the end of March 2015 which will allow us to build a stable release. This feature set would contain all features which worked in V2 so a migration would be possible. Any migration would not work out of the box since we changed the architecture with our V4 implementation. But the general idea of having an EdmProvider and Processor Interfaces which have to be implemented still persists. So a move from V2 to V4 should not be too difficult.
Best Regards,
Christian
From: Peter Lawrence [mailto:peter.lawrence@inova8.com<ma...@inova8.com>]
Sent: Dienstag, 25. November 2014 05:25
To: user@olingo.apache.org<ma...@olingo.apache.org>
Subject: Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than EdmSimpleTypeKind
Question 1: Is my interpretation correct that Olingo2 only supports EdmSimpleTypeKind of parameters for FunctionImports?
For example i want to declare the following
<FunctionImport Name="createRDFSClass" ReturnType="rdfs.Class" EntitySet="rdfs_Class" >
<Parameter Name="class" Type="rdfs.Class" Nullable="false"/>
<Parameter Name="label" Type="Edm.String" Nullable="true"/>
</FunctionImport>
Question 2: It also appears that Olingo4 does support parameters of type other than EdmSimpleType. Is that correct?
Question 3: When do you anticipate releasing Olingo4, and have you any suggestions regarding migration of an Olingo2 provider?
Many thanks
Peter J. Lawrence
inova8
Providing answers for users' information questions
Mobile: +1 330 631 3772<tel:%2B1%20330%20631%203772> | Phone: +1 330 342 0582<tel:%2B1%20330%20342%200582> | UK Cell:+44 795 563 2824<tel:%2B44%20795%20563%202824> |Skype: PeterJLawrence
Email: peter.lawrence@inova8.com<ma...@inova8.com> | Web: www.inova8.com<http://www.inova8.com>
LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence
Re: Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than EdmSimpleTypeKind
Posted by Peter Lawrence <pe...@inova8.com>.
Thanks for your response.
With regard to Question 1, V3 suggests support for EntityType parameters
(but not complex types). In which case one can compose a request such as:
.../rdfs_Class(2)/createRDFSClass(label='abc')
where the entityType parameter is bindable as specified in the edm:
<FunctionImport Name="createRDFSClass" ReturnType="rdfs.Class"
EntitySet="rdfs_Class" IsBindable="true" IsSideEffecting="true" >
<Parameter Name="class" Type="rdfs.Class" Nullable="false"/>
<Parameter Name="label" Type="Edm.String" Nullable="true"/>
</FunctionImport>
Is this possible in olingo2 (the clue to my answer maybe in the fact that
Olingo2 is OData2!)
Many thanks for your help and your work on Olingo
Peter
*Peter J. Lawrence*
*inova8*
*Providing answers for users' information questions*
*Mobile:* +1 330 631 3772 | *Phone:* +1 330 342 0582 | *UK Cell*:+44 795
563 2824 |*Skype:* PeterJLawrence
*Email:* peter.lawrence@inova8.com | *Web:* www.inova8.com
*LinkedIn: **http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence
<http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence>*
On Tue, Nov 25, 2014 at 7:59 AM, Amend, Christian <ch...@sap.com>
wrote:
> Hi,
>
>
>
> 1. Yes we only support simple types for function import paramters since
> there is no specified way in V2 on how to transport a complex type via the
> URI.
>
>
>
> 2. Yes in V4 there is a specified way in which complex structures have to
> be written in the URI so we will support this in our V4 implementation.
>
>
>
> 3. There is no concrete day I could tell you. We hope to have a feature
> set by the end of March 2015 which will allow us to build a stable release.
> This feature set would contain all features which worked in V2 so a
> migration would be possible. Any migration would not work out of the box
> since we changed the architecture with our V4 implementation. But the
> general idea of having an EdmProvider and Processor Interfaces which have
> to be implemented still persists. So a move from V2 to V4 should not be too
> difficult.
>
>
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Christian
>
>
>
> *From:* Peter Lawrence [mailto:peter.lawrence@inova8.com]
> *Sent:* Dienstag, 25. November 2014 05:25
> *To:* user@olingo.apache.org
> *Subject:* Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than
> EdmSimpleTypeKind
>
>
>
> Question 1: Is my interpretation correct that Olingo2 only supports
> EdmSimpleTypeKind of parameters for FunctionImports?
>
>
>
> For example i want to declare the following
>
>
>
> <FunctionImport Name="createRDFSClass" ReturnType="rdfs.Class"
> EntitySet="rdfs_Class" >
>
> <Parameter Name="class" Type=*"rdfs.Class"*
> Nullable="false"/>
>
> <Parameter Name="label" Type="Edm.String"
> Nullable="true"/>
>
> </FunctionImport>
>
>
>
> Question 2: It also appears that Olingo4 does support parameters of type
> other than EdmSimpleType. Is that correct?
>
>
>
> Question 3: When do you anticipate releasing Olingo4, and have you any
> suggestions regarding migration of an Olingo2 provider?
>
>
>
> Many thanks
>
>
>
>
>
> *Peter J. Lawrence*
>
> *inova**8*
>
> *Providing answers for users' information questions*
>
> *Mobile:* +1 330 631 3772 | *Phone:* +1 330 342 0582 | *UK Cell*:+44 795
> 563 2824 |*Skype:* PeterJLawrence
>
> *Email:* peter.lawrence@inova8.com | *Web:* www.inova8.com
>
> *LinkedIn: **http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence
> <http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence>*
>
RE: Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than
EdmSimpleTypeKind
Posted by "Amend, Christian" <ch...@sap.com>.
Hi,
1. Yes we only support simple types for function import paramters since there is no specified way in V2 on how to transport a complex type via the URI.
2. Yes in V4 there is a specified way in which complex structures have to be written in the URI so we will support this in our V4 implementation.
3. There is no concrete day I could tell you. We hope to have a feature set by the end of March 2015 which will allow us to build a stable release. This feature set would contain all features which worked in V2 so a migration would be possible. Any migration would not work out of the box since we changed the architecture with our V4 implementation. But the general idea of having an EdmProvider and Processor Interfaces which have to be implemented still persists. So a move from V2 to V4 should not be too difficult.
Best Regards,
Christian
From: Peter Lawrence [mailto:peter.lawrence@inova8.com]
Sent: Dienstag, 25. November 2014 05:25
To: user@olingo.apache.org
Subject: Olingo2 support for FunctionImportParameter other than EdmSimpleTypeKind
Question 1: Is my interpretation correct that Olingo2 only supports EdmSimpleTypeKind of parameters for FunctionImports?
For example i want to declare the following
<FunctionImport Name="createRDFSClass" ReturnType="rdfs.Class" EntitySet="rdfs_Class" >
<Parameter Name="class" Type="rdfs.Class" Nullable="false"/>
<Parameter Name="label" Type="Edm.String" Nullable="true"/>
</FunctionImport>
Question 2: It also appears that Olingo4 does support parameters of type other than EdmSimpleType. Is that correct?
Question 3: When do you anticipate releasing Olingo4, and have you any suggestions regarding migration of an Olingo2 provider?
Many thanks
Peter J. Lawrence
inova8
Providing answers for users' information questions
Mobile: +1 330 631 3772 | Phone: +1 330 342 0582 | UK Cell:+44 795 563 2824 |Skype: PeterJLawrence
Email: peter.lawrence@inova8.com<ma...@inova8.com> | Web: www.inova8.com<http://www.inova8.com>
LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/peterjohnlawrence