You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to xml-commons-dev@xerces.apache.org by David Crossley <cr...@apache.org> on 2003/07/07 09:39:52 UTC

some issues with docs: license review

While trying to build the XML Commons website, i am running
into quite a lot of issues.

Licenses is one issue. I was first attracted by some tricky
copyright bits in the Resolver documentation, but ended up finding
some discrepancies elsewhere too.

I Cc the PMC so that they can help to ensure that all is ship-shape.

Here is a summary of the state of the CVS. I have listed everything
that i could find. Some are okay, some need attention.

-------------------------------------------------------
1) xml-commons/LICENSE.txt
----------
 * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
 *
 * Copyright (c) 2001-2002 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
 * reserved.
...
----------

I just updated that to say 2001-2003

-------------------------------------------------------
2) xml-commons/README.txt
----------

This notes that there are a number of different licenses for the
files under xml-commons/java/external (except for a couple of specific
files) and goes on to say that the catchall licence is that from 1).
Sounds okay to me, but IANAL.

-------------------------------------------------------
3) xml-commons/src/documentation/content/xdocs/licenses.xml
----------

This is a combination of 1) and 2) and will get rendered as the
webpage commons/licenses.html

-------------------------------------------------------
4) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/LICENSE
----------
 * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
 *
 *
 * Copyright (c) 2001 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
 * reserved.
...
----------

This has different text to 1) and a different way to define "year"
(which is still 2001). It refers to "Xalan" rather than "Apache"
and additionally refers to IBM. I wonder if that is a relic from
copying another license.

This license also conflicts with a statement from 2). I suggest
that this gets replaced by 1) unless there is a reason for the
differences. 

-------------------------------------------------------
5) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/env/Which*.java
----------

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

-------------------------------------------------------
6) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/*.java

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

A couple of files say "Lotus" instead of IBM.

If 4) is replaced by 1) then these headers would change too.

-------------------------------------------------------
7) xml-commons/java/tests/resolver/src/*.java
----------

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

-------------------------------------------------------
8) xml-commons/java/docs/resolver.xml
----------

The entity resolver article has had many lives.
Now there is this version at xml-commons.

The document has the following explicit copyright statements, which
will get rendered when Forrest generates the HTML documentation.
----------
Copyright © 2001, 2002 Sun Microsystems, Inc.
Copyright © 2000 Arbortext, Inc.
----------
Do we just add "2003 ASF" as an additional holder?

Forrest will also automatically add this to the bottom
of the page footer ...
----------
Copyright © 2003 The Apache Software Foundation. All rights reserved.
----------
I presume that that sits okay with the abovementioned explicit
statements for past years

Also this Resolver article links to a copyright.html which
does not exist. Should this link to the licence at 5) ?

-------------------------------------------------------
9) xml-commons/java/docs/release-notes.xml
----------

The resolver release notes have the copyright holder as Sun.
Perhaps this should be only ASF because the notes cover the
xml-commons release of Resolver.

-------------------------------------------------------
10) xml-commons/java/external/src/javax/xml/transform/*
----------

These have embedded license as per 1)

They still say "2001". Some files have not been edited since 2001,
some have been.

A couple of files an additional bit tacked on the end which
refers to prior work by Sun 1999-2001.

-------------------------------------------------------
11) xml-commons/java/external/src/javax/xml/parsers/*
----------

These have embedded license as per 1)

All files have an additional bit tacked on the end which
refers to prior work by Sun 1999-2001.

They still say "2001". Some files have not been edited since 2001,
some have been.

-------------------------------------------------------
12) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/apache/*
----------

The only stuff in here is xmlcommons/Version.*
These have the "Lotus" variation of 4)

They have not been edited since 2001.

-------------------------------------------------------
13) xml-commons/java/external/LICENSE.dom-*.txt
----------

Very liberal licence by W3C. I cannot see any conflicts.

-------------------------------------------------------
14) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/w3c/dom/*
----------

These all have a short W3C license header. Seems okay.

Still says "2000". Some files have been edited in 2002.

-------------------------------------------------------
15) xml-commons/java/external/xdocs/dom/*
----------

There are various "copyright" documents here which i have not
yet explored.

-------------------------------------------------------
16) xml-commons/java/external/LICENSE.sax.txt
----------

This makes very explicit statements that everything is released
into the Public Domain.

However, there is a bit of confusing additional comments here
about the document being out-of-date.

-------------------------------------------------------
17) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/xml/sax/*
----------

Most files simply say ...
// No warranty; no copyright -- use this as you will.

Some simply say ...
// NO WARRANTY!  This class is in the Public Domain.

-------------------------------------------------------
18) xml-commons/java/external/xdocs/sax/*
----------

Each document has a simple statement ...
"This document is in the Public Domain."

-------------------------------------------------------
19) xml-commons/java/src/manifest.which and
xml-commons/java/external/src/manifest.commons
----------

Both say that they are created by Sun Microsystems,
- seems a little strange. Or does it mean that the manifest
file format is created by them.

-------------------------------------------------------
20) All java code has got a licence header.
----------

Yes, all java files are complete.

-------------------------------------------------------
21) Up-to-date "year" on copyright statements
----------

Does each file's copyright statement need to be updated
if that file has been modified?

-------------------------------------------------------





Re: some issues with docs: license review

Posted by David Crossley <cr...@indexgeo.com.au>.
Berin Lautenbach wrote:
> David Crossley wrote:
> 
> > Thanks Norm, i have applied the suggested changes to the
> > resolver side of things. Waiting on the PMC for the other
> > issues (4.5 down, 13.5 to go).
> 
> Whoops.  I've missed something here - many apologies!
> 
> Could you re-post the issues in question?

Sure, see below. As per yesterday's message, the "resolver"
issues are fixed. I am not sure whether to keep copying
the PMC or just deal with it on commons-dev (because all
XML project folks should be there anyway).

--David

-----Original Message-----
Sender: David Crossley
To: commons-dev<AT>xml.apache.org, pmc<AT>xml.apache.org
Subject: some issues with docs: license review
Date: 07 Jul 2003 17:39:52 +1000

While trying to build the XML Commons website, i am running
into quite a lot of issues.

Licenses is one issue. I was first attracted by some tricky
copyright bits in the Resolver documentation, but ended up finding
some discrepancies elsewhere too.

I Cc the PMC so that they can help to ensure that all is ship-shape.

Here is a summary of the state of the CVS. I have listed everything
that i could find. Some are okay, some need attention.

-------------------------------------------------------
1) xml-commons/LICENSE.txt
----------
 * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
 *
 * Copyright (c) 2001-2002 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
 * reserved.
...
----------

I just updated that to say 2001-2003

-------------------------------------------------------
2) xml-commons/README.txt
----------

This notes that there are a number of different licenses for the
files under xml-commons/java/external (except for a couple of specific
files) and goes on to say that the catchall licence is that from 1).
Sounds okay to me, but IANAL.

-------------------------------------------------------
3) xml-commons/src/documentation/content/xdocs/licenses.xml
----------

This is a combination of 1) and 2) and will get rendered as the
webpage commons/licenses.html

-------------------------------------------------------
4) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/LICENSE
----------
 * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
 *
 *
 * Copyright (c) 2001 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
 * reserved.
...
----------

This has different text to 1) and a different way to define "year"
(which is still 2001). It refers to "Xalan" rather than "Apache"
and additionally refers to IBM. I wonder if that is a relic from
copying another license.

This license also conflicts with a statement from 2). I suggest
that this gets replaced by 1) unless there is a reason for the
differences. 

-------------------------------------------------------
5) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/env/Which*.java
----------

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

-------------------------------------------------------
6) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/*.java

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

A couple of files say "Lotus" instead of IBM.

If 4) is replaced by 1) then these headers would change too.

-------------------------------------------------------
7) xml-commons/java/tests/resolver/src/*.java
----------

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

-------------------------------------------------------
8) xml-commons/java/docs/resolver.xml
----------

The entity resolver article has had many lives.
Now there is this version at xml-commons.

The document has the following explicit copyright statements, which
will get rendered when Forrest generates the HTML documentation.
----------
Copyright © 2001, 2002 Sun Microsystems, Inc.
Copyright © 2000 Arbortext, Inc.
----------
Do we just add "2003 ASF" as an additional holder?

Forrest will also automatically add this to the bottom
of the page footer ...
----------
Copyright © 2003 The Apache Software Foundation. All rights reserved.
----------
I presume that that sits okay with the abovementioned explicit
statements for past years

Also this Resolver article links to a copyright.html which
does not exist. Should this link to the licence at 5) ?

-------------------------------------------------------
9) xml-commons/java/docs/release-notes.xml
----------

The resolver release notes have the copyright holder as Sun.
Perhaps this should be only ASF because the notes cover the
xml-commons release of Resolver.

-------------------------------------------------------
10) xml-commons/java/external/src/javax/xml/transform/*
----------

These have embedded license as per 1)

They still say "2001". Some files have not been edited since 2001,
some have been.

A couple of files an additional bit tacked on the end which
refers to prior work by Sun 1999-2001.

-------------------------------------------------------
11) xml-commons/java/external/src/javax/xml/parsers/*
----------

These have embedded license as per 1)

All files have an additional bit tacked on the end which
refers to prior work by Sun 1999-2001.

They still say "2001". Some files have not been edited since 2001,
some have been.

-------------------------------------------------------
12) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/apache/*
----------

The only stuff in here is xmlcommons/Version.*
These have the "Lotus" variation of 4)

They have not been edited since 2001.

-------------------------------------------------------
13) xml-commons/java/external/LICENSE.dom-*.txt
----------

Very liberal licence by W3C. I cannot see any conflicts.

-------------------------------------------------------
14) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/w3c/dom/*
----------

These all have a short W3C license header. Seems okay.

Still says "2000". Some files have been edited in 2002.

-------------------------------------------------------
15) xml-commons/java/external/xdocs/dom/*
----------

There are various "copyright" documents here which i have not
yet explored.

-------------------------------------------------------
16) xml-commons/java/external/LICENSE.sax.txt
----------

This makes very explicit statements that everything is released
into the Public Domain.

However, there is a bit of confusing additional comments here
about the document being out-of-date.

-------------------------------------------------------
17) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/xml/sax/*
----------

Most files simply say ...
// No warranty; no copyright -- use this as you will.

Some simply say ...
// NO WARRANTY!  This class is in the Public Domain.

-------------------------------------------------------
18) xml-commons/java/external/xdocs/sax/*
----------

Each document has a simple statement ...
"This document is in the Public Domain."

-------------------------------------------------------
19) xml-commons/java/src/manifest.which and
xml-commons/java/external/src/manifest.commons
----------

Both say that they are created by Sun Microsystems,
- seems a little strange. Or does it mean that the manifest
file format is created by them.

-------------------------------------------------------
20) All java code has got a licence header.
----------

Yes, all java files are complete.

-------------------------------------------------------
21) Up-to-date "year" on copyright statements
----------

Does each file's copyright statement need to be updated
if that file has been modified?

------------------------------------------------------------Forwarded Message-----


From: David Crossley <cr...@apache.org>
To: commons-dev@xml.apache.org, pmc@xml.apache.org
Subject: some issues with docs: license review
Date: 07 Jul 2003 17:39:52 +1000

While trying to build the XML Commons website, i am running
into quite a lot of issues.

Licenses is one issue. I was first attracted by some tricky
copyright bits in the Resolver documentation, but ended up finding
some discrepancies elsewhere too.

I Cc the PMC so that they can help to ensure that all is ship-shape.

Here is a summary of the state of the CVS. I have listed everything
that i could find. Some are okay, some need attention.

-------------------------------------------------------
1) xml-commons/LICENSE.txt
----------
 * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
 *
 * Copyright (c) 2001-2002 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
 * reserved.
...
----------

I just updated that to say 2001-2003

-------------------------------------------------------
2) xml-commons/README.txt
----------

This notes that there are a number of different licenses for the
files under xml-commons/java/external (except for a couple of specific
files) and goes on to say that the catchall licence is that from 1).
Sounds okay to me, but IANAL.

-------------------------------------------------------
3) xml-commons/src/documentation/content/xdocs/licenses.xml
----------

This is a combination of 1) and 2) and will get rendered as the
webpage commons/licenses.html

-------------------------------------------------------
4) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/LICENSE
----------
 * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
 *
 *
 * Copyright (c) 2001 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
 * reserved.
...
----------

This has different text to 1) and a different way to define "year"
(which is still 2001). It refers to "Xalan" rather than "Apache"
and additionally refers to IBM. I wonder if that is a relic from
copying another license.

This license also conflicts with a statement from 2). I suggest
that this gets replaced by 1) unless there is a reason for the
differences. 

-------------------------------------------------------
5) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/env/Which*.java
----------

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

-------------------------------------------------------
6) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/*.java

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

A couple of files say "Lotus" instead of IBM.

If 4) is replaced by 1) then these headers would change too.

-------------------------------------------------------
7) xml-commons/java/tests/resolver/src/*.java
----------

These have embedded license as per 4)
i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

-------------------------------------------------------
8) xml-commons/java/docs/resolver.xml
----------

The entity resolver article has had many lives.
Now there is this version at xml-commons.

The document has the following explicit copyright statements, which
will get rendered when Forrest generates the HTML documentation.
----------
Copyright © 2001, 2002 Sun Microsystems, Inc.
Copyright © 2000 Arbortext, Inc.
----------
Do we just add "2003 ASF" as an additional holder?

Forrest will also automatically add this to the bottom
of the page footer ...
----------
Copyright © 2003 The Apache Software Foundation. All rights reserved.
----------
I presume that that sits okay with the abovementioned explicit
statements for past years

Also this Resolver article links to a copyright.html which
does not exist. Should this link to the licence at 5) ?

-------------------------------------------------------
9) xml-commons/java/docs/release-notes.xml
----------

The resolver release notes have the copyright holder as Sun.
Perhaps this should be only ASF because the notes cover the
xml-commons release of Resolver.

-------------------------------------------------------
10) xml-commons/java/external/src/javax/xml/transform/*
----------

These have embedded license as per 1)

They still say "2001". Some files have not been edited since 2001,
some have been.

A couple of files an additional bit tacked on the end which
refers to prior work by Sun 1999-2001.

-------------------------------------------------------
11) xml-commons/java/external/src/javax/xml/parsers/*
----------

These have embedded license as per 1)

All files have an additional bit tacked on the end which
refers to prior work by Sun 1999-2001.

They still say "2001". Some files have not been edited since 2001,
some have been.

-------------------------------------------------------
12) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/apache/*
----------

The only stuff in here is xmlcommons/Version.*
These have the "Lotus" variation of 4)

They have not been edited since 2001.

-------------------------------------------------------
13) xml-commons/java/external/LICENSE.dom-*.txt
----------

Very liberal licence by W3C. I cannot see any conflicts.

-------------------------------------------------------
14) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/w3c/dom/*
----------

These all have a short W3C license header. Seems okay.

Still says "2000". Some files have been edited in 2002.

-------------------------------------------------------
15) xml-commons/java/external/xdocs/dom/*
----------

There are various "copyright" documents here which i have not
yet explored.

-------------------------------------------------------
16) xml-commons/java/external/LICENSE.sax.txt
----------

This makes very explicit statements that everything is released
into the Public Domain.

However, there is a bit of confusing additional comments here
about the document being out-of-date.

-------------------------------------------------------
17) xml-commons/java/external/src/org/xml/sax/*
----------

Most files simply say ...
// No warranty; no copyright -- use this as you will.

Some simply say ...
// NO WARRANTY!  This class is in the Public Domain.

-------------------------------------------------------
18) xml-commons/java/external/xdocs/sax/*
----------

Each document has a simple statement ...
"This document is in the Public Domain."

-------------------------------------------------------
19) xml-commons/java/src/manifest.which and
xml-commons/java/external/src/manifest.commons
----------

Both say that they are created by Sun Microsystems,
- seems a little strange. Or does it mean that the manifest
file format is created by them.

-------------------------------------------------------
20) All java code has got a licence header.
----------

Yes, all java files are complete.

-------------------------------------------------------
21) Up-to-date "year" on copyright statements
----------

Does each file's copyright statement need to be updated
if that file has been modified?

-------------------------------------------------------



Re: some issues with docs: license review

Posted by Berin Lautenbach <be...@ozemail.com.au>.
David Crossley wrote:

> Thanks Norm, i have applied the suggested changes to the
> resolver side of things. Waiting on the PMC for the other
> issues (4.5 down, 13.5 to go).

Whoops.  I've missed something here - many apologies!

Could you re-post the issues in question?

Cheers,
	Berin


Re: some issues with docs: license review

Posted by David Crossley <cr...@indexgeo.com.au>.
On 2003-07-11 Norman Walsh wrote:
> David Crossley was heard to say:
> | While trying to build the XML Commons website, i am running
> | into quite a lot of issues.
> |
> | Licenses is one issue. I was first attracted by some tricky
> | copyright bits in the Resolver documentation, but ended up finding
> | some discrepancies elsewhere too.
> 
> Um, I'll be happy to try to straighten out the resolver bits.

Thanks Norm, i have applied the suggested changes to the
resolver side of things. Waiting on the PMC for the other
issues (4.5 down, 13.5 to go).

More discussion below ...

> [...]
> | -------------------------------------------------------
> | 4) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/LICENSE
> | ----------
> |  * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
> |  *
> |  *
> |  * Copyright (c) 2001 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
> |  * reserved.
> | ...
> | ----------
> |
> | This has different text to 1) and a different way to define "year"
> | (which is still 2001). It refers to "Xalan" rather than "Apache"
> | and additionally refers to IBM. I wonder if that is a relic from
> | copying another license.
> 
> I'm sure it is. When I moved it to Apache I was told it had to have
> the Apache Software License in every file, so I "cut-and-pasted" it
> from another file. I must have chosen my source poorly.
> 
> I suggest it be globally replaced with the proper license.

Done.

> [...]
> | -------------------------------------------------------
> | 6) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/*.java
> |
> | These have embedded license as per 4)
> | i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".
> |
> | A couple of files say "Lotus" instead of IBM.
> |
> | If 4) is replaced by 1) then these headers would change too.
> 
> Yes.

Done.

> | -------------------------------------------------------
> | 7) xml-commons/java/tests/resolver/src/*.java
> | ----------
> |
> | These have embedded license as per 4)
> | i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".
> 
> Ditto.

Done.

> | -------------------------------------------------------
> | 8) xml-commons/java/docs/resolver.xml
> | ----------
> |
> | The entity resolver article has had many lives.
> | Now there is this version at xml-commons.
> 
> It has indeed.
> 
> | The document has the following explicit copyright statements, which
> | will get rendered when Forrest generates the HTML documentation.
> | ----------
> | Copyright © 2001, 2002 Sun Microsystems, Inc.
> | Copyright © 2000 Arbortext, Inc.
> | ----------
> | Do we just add "2003 ASF" as an additional holder?
> |
> | Forrest will also automatically add this to the bottom
> | of the page footer ...
> | ----------
> | Copyright © 2003 The Apache Software Foundation. All rights reserved.
> | ----------
> | I presume that that sits okay with the abovementioned explicit
> | statements for past years
> 
> I'm comfortable that it does. If something more explicit than my
> comfort is required, then I can pursue it.

Okay, i have added ASF for 2003. The PMC can please speak up if
something else is required. 

> Or I can pull this doc out
> of the repository and just publish it separately, but I'd rather not.

Please keep it here in xml-commons. This is the main reason
that i am trying to help get the xml-commons website published.
The resolver is such an important tool.

> | Also this Resolver article links to a copyright.html which
> | does not exist. Should this link to the licence at 5) ?
> 
> Yes, that's fine.

This is not yet done, as i need to find a way to get Forrest
to link to documents in other parts of the tree.
(I meant link to item 3 of course, not 5.)

> | -------------------------------------------------------
> | 9) xml-commons/java/docs/release-notes.xml
> | ----------
> |
> | The resolver release notes have the copyright holder as Sun.
> | Perhaps this should be only ASF because the notes cover the
> | xml-commons release of Resolver.
> 
> Yeah, I probably forgot to cut-and-paste that one.

Fixed.

Thanks again Norm
--David





Re: some issues with docs: license review

Posted by Norman Walsh <nd...@nwalsh.com>.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

/ David Crossley <cr...@apache.org> was heard to say:
| While trying to build the XML Commons website, i am running
| into quite a lot of issues.
|
| Licenses is one issue. I was first attracted by some tricky
| copyright bits in the Resolver documentation, but ended up finding
| some discrepancies elsewhere too.

Um, I'll be happy to try to straighten out the resolver bits.

[...]
| -------------------------------------------------------
| 4) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/LICENSE
| ----------
|  * The Apache Software License, Version 1.1
|  *
|  *
|  * Copyright (c) 2001 The Apache Software Foundation.  All rights
|  * reserved.
| ...
| ----------
|
| This has different text to 1) and a different way to define "year"
| (which is still 2001). It refers to "Xalan" rather than "Apache"
| and additionally refers to IBM. I wonder if that is a relic from
| copying another license.

I'm sure it is. When I moved it to Apache I was told it had to have
the Apache Software License in every file, so I "cut-and-pasted" it
from another file. I must have chosen my source poorly.

I suggest it be globally replaced with the proper license.

[...]
| -------------------------------------------------------
| 6) xml-commons/java/src/org/apache/xml/resolver/*.java
|
| These have embedded license as per 4)
| i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".
|
| A couple of files say "Lotus" instead of IBM.
|
| If 4) is replaced by 1) then these headers would change too.

Yes.

| -------------------------------------------------------
| 7) xml-commons/java/tests/resolver/src/*.java
| ----------
|
| These have embedded license as per 4)
| i.e. they mention Xalan and IBM and still say "2001".

Ditto.

| -------------------------------------------------------
| 8) xml-commons/java/docs/resolver.xml
| ----------
|
| The entity resolver article has had many lives.
| Now there is this version at xml-commons.

It has indeed.

| The document has the following explicit copyright statements, which
| will get rendered when Forrest generates the HTML documentation.
| ----------
| Copyright © 2001, 2002 Sun Microsystems, Inc.
| Copyright © 2000 Arbortext, Inc.
| ----------
| Do we just add "2003 ASF" as an additional holder?
|
| Forrest will also automatically add this to the bottom
| of the page footer ...
| ----------
| Copyright © 2003 The Apache Software Foundation. All rights reserved.
| ----------
| I presume that that sits okay with the abovementioned explicit
| statements for past years

I'm comfortable that it does. If something more explicit than my
comfort is required, then I can pursue it. Or I can pull this doc out
of the repository and just publish it separately, but I'd rather not.

| Also this Resolver article links to a copyright.html which
| does not exist. Should this link to the licence at 5) ?

Yes, that's fine.

| -------------------------------------------------------
| 9) xml-commons/java/docs/release-notes.xml
| ----------
|
| The resolver release notes have the copyright holder as Sun.
| Perhaps this should be only ASF because the notes cover the
| xml-commons release of Resolver.

Yeah, I probably forgot to cut-and-paste that one.

                                        Be seeing you,
                                          norm

- -- 
Norman.Walsh@Sun.COM    | Things work out best for those who make the
XML Standards Architect | best of the way things work out.
Web Tech. and Standards |
Sun Microsystems, Inc.  | 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Processed by Mailcrypt 3.5.7 <http://mailcrypt.sourceforge.net/>

iD8DBQE/DbewOyltUcwYWjsRAkEHAJwPH1kF4/DTVCAIPQCh3Gup570fEgCfei/C
uDMZE5vMPpmIx8loSnSrXUs=
=NOJB
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----