You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Justin Mason <jm...@jmason.org> on 2004/07/20 01:54:49 UTC
Re: [RDJ] Is it broken?
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Hey guys --
suggestion: how's about sending out new versions as ZIP files via a
mailing list? ie. turn it from "pull" into "push"?
if you provide a script, it should be possible to automate something that
users can put into /etc/aliases, then subscribe that address to the "RDJ
list" -- and the updates get auto-installed as they're generated.
It'd also be a handy way to spread the load of HTTP service; each mirror
host has an alias that extracts the files and puts them onto its mirror.
- --j.
Gary Smith writes:
> Damn, didn't know things were going that bad for you guys...
>
> I guess all that talk about letting us help you mirror to reduce the load was missed somewhere in the stream of emails. Anyways, I have my scripts set for:
>
> 0 6 * * * /root/cronjobs/mailstats.sh
> 45 5 * * * /etc/mail/spamassassin/my_rules_du_jour.sh
>
> And I'm still getting the error all weekend. Rate limited is broken guys...
>
> So, yes I can just dump RDJ and copy the files to a central location daily. It's not a problem. I just think you're going about it in a complety odd way. Force the wget's to authenticate. Force rate limiting based on performance and not denial, have a list of active subscribers that aren't rate limited by IP.
>
> Gary
>
>
> ________________________________
>
> From: Fred [mailto:spamassassin@freddyt.com]
> Sent: Mon 7/19/2004 3:13 PM
> To: Chris Santerre; Spamassassin-Talk (E-mail)
> Subject: Re: [RDJ] Is it broken?
>
> Gary Smith wrote:
> > Even after the problem has been fixed with RDJ it will just mask the
> > fact that we cannot connect to the server. Basically, we will never
> > know that it failed because no update occured.
>
> True, however, in my cron scripts I am alerted of errors or output from any
> script which is run. If you check the output of those scripts you will see
> when things go bad.
>
> I'm a member of SARE and I'm all for the ratelimiter. we spend a great
> deal of time and effort doing our thing and some admins are irresponsible
> enough to set updates for once every 2 minutes. We have to protect
> ourselves, if people are going to abuse free services (AND YOU KNOW THEY
> WILL) those people providing free services need to find ways to keep
> themselves in business or limit the abusers so it doesn't affect the rest.
>
> This rate limiter is a wake up call for anyone doing more than 1 update per
> day. Even if it is 5 seperate servers behind a proxy. This is free stuff
> you are abusing, please stop abusing it and re-implement your method of
> doing things. If you know that each of those 4-5 servers will download the
> same files each day, wouldn't it be best to download to a central location
> and then have your servers get it from there? It seems having all servers
> download straight from us is the lazy approach. (the same lazy approach
> that causes traffic congestion in all parts of my life), if people car
> pooled more, we would have more room on the roads, if people buy in bulk,
> you don't have to revisit the same stores so often. If virus writers used
> IRC more often, they would not have to flood the entire internet with port
> scans looking for their zombies. In my book (and this is not directly
> towards anyone in specific) this is all due to being lazy. (it's easier to
> flood internet with packets looking for zombies than to have the zombies
> phone home?) (it's easier if you jump in your own car and drive yourself to
> work versus waiting for someone else) We often value ease without thinking
> of the consequences of our actions. For once, we have the ability to force
> people to follow our restrictions and I'll fight to keep it in effect (AS
> SOON AS WE GET THE BUGS WORKED OUT).
>
> RDJ to an central storage, then you could even have your servers run RDJ on
> that location to check for updates.
>
> The problem was a few people made such bad mistakes that we have to make
> changes which affect everyone. We don't like putting limits on things like
> this and if it wasn't to protect our own butts we would not have done it.
>
> SARE is run by donation from people and businesses combined. We have a
> business that donated a shell account and bandwidth. If we abuse the free
> donation, we'll be looking for a new home. If people setup mirrors, then
> everyone can hammer the mirrors all they want, as long as it doesn't
> threaten our very existance.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.4 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Exmh CVS
iD8DBQFA/F9JQTcbUG5Y7woRAgVaAKDa5l6bvD1OuSVii318yVqjxdULzwCgsGqV
gwCt2bj49AgHmFet5GGEKho=
=8pRW
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----