You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to server-dev@james.apache.org by "Anastasia Tugaenko (JIRA)" <se...@james.apache.org> on 2010/06/10 15:04:14 UTC
[jira] Created: (JAMES-1018) James SMTP server while redirecting
mail sends it to itself rather than to the destination
James SMTP server while redirecting mail sends it to itself rather than to the destination
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key: JAMES-1018
URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-1018
Project: JAMES Server
Issue Type: Bug
Components: SMTPServer
Affects Versions: 2.3.1
Environment: Windows XP
Reporter: Anastasia Tugaenko
Priority: Minor
Under certain network and DNS configuration James SMTP server version 2.3.1 sends mail to itself rather than to the next hop. As a result, the mail loops until resending limit is exceeded. It never gets to the destination.
Configuration
The configuration file - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/config.xml.
The issue was reproduced in a virtual network with three nodes and two domains (see http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/virtualNet.png):
1. network vbox1.test with nodes XP11 and XP12,
2. network vbox2.test with nodes XP21 and XP22;
3. nodes XP11 and XP21 are physically on the same virtual machine where James SMTP server runs. DNS runs on the same server.
DNS configuration used to reproduces the issue is available here - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/etc.zip.
The issue occurs when MX record for XP21 has higher priority than that of XP22.
XP22 IN MX 15 XP21
XP22 IN MX 25 XP22
Steps to reproduce the issue:
1. Turn on the virtual machines for nodes XP11/XP21, XP12, XP22. Launch DNS and James SMTP on the XP11/XP21 virtual machine. Launch mail agents on XP12 and XP22.
2. Send a mail from XP12 to XP22 (e.g. to user@XP22.vbox2.test).
Issue:
Mail agent on XP12 sends the mail to the James SMTP server on XP11. The James SMTP server re-sends the mail to itself (the MX record priority is higher than that of XP22). As a result the mail never arrives to XP22.
James SMTP log is available here - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/smtpserver.log.
Here is an extract from it:
09/06/10 16:54:51 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP12 (192.168.56.22)
09/06/10 16:54:52 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088091716-0 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.56.22 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
09/06/10 16:55:32 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
09/06/10 16:55:32 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088132675-1 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
09/06/10 16:56:12 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
09/06/10 16:56:12 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088172782-2 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
09/06/10 16:56:52 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
09/06/10 16:56:52 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088212910-3 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
The log shows that the mail gets constantly re-sent from XP11 to XP12 (the same physical machine) and never arrives to the destination. We tried other open-source SMTP servers in the same configuration - they do not loop and deliver the mail to the next hop.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: server-dev-unsubscribe@james.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: server-dev-help@james.apache.org
[jira] Commented: (JAMES-1018) James SMTP server while redirecting
mail sends it to itself rather than to the destination
Posted by "Norman Maurer (JIRA)" <se...@james.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-1018?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=12882659#action_12882659 ]
Norman Maurer commented on JAMES-1018:
--------------------------------------
At the moment I not understand the exact problem.. I will investigate a bit more.
> James SMTP server while redirecting mail sends it to itself rather than to the destination
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JAMES-1018
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-1018
> Project: JAMES Server
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SMTPServer
> Affects Versions: 2.3.1
> Environment: Windows XP
> Reporter: Anastasia Tugaenko
> Priority: Minor
>
> Under certain network and DNS configuration James SMTP server version 2.3.1 sends mail to itself rather than to the next hop. As a result, the mail loops until resending limit is exceeded. It never gets to the destination.
>
> Configuration
> The configuration file - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/config.xml.
> The issue was reproduced in a virtual network with three nodes and two domains (see http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/virtualNet.png):
> 1. network vbox1.test with nodes XP11 and XP12,
> 2. network vbox2.test with nodes XP21 and XP22;
> 3. nodes XP11 and XP21 are physically on the same virtual machine where James SMTP server runs. DNS runs on the same server.
> DNS configuration used to reproduces the issue is available here - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/etc.zip.
> The issue occurs when MX record for XP21 has higher priority than that of XP22.
> XP22 IN MX 15 XP21
> XP22 IN MX 25 XP22
> Steps to reproduce the issue:
> 1. Turn on the virtual machines for nodes XP11/XP21, XP12, XP22. Launch DNS and James SMTP on the XP11/XP21 virtual machine. Launch mail agents on XP12 and XP22.
> 2. Send a mail from XP12 to XP22 (e.g. to user@XP22.vbox2.test).
>
> Issue:
> Mail agent on XP12 sends the mail to the James SMTP server on XP11. The James SMTP server re-sends the mail to itself (the MX record priority is higher than that of XP22). As a result the mail never arrives to XP22.
> James SMTP log is available here - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/smtpserver.log.
> Here is an extract from it:
> 09/06/10 16:54:51 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP12 (192.168.56.22)
> 09/06/10 16:54:52 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088091716-0 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.56.22 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> 09/06/10 16:55:32 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
> 09/06/10 16:55:32 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088132675-1 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> 09/06/10 16:56:12 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
> 09/06/10 16:56:12 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088172782-2 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> 09/06/10 16:56:52 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
> 09/06/10 16:56:52 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088212910-3 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> The log shows that the mail gets constantly re-sent from XP11 to XP12 (the same physical machine) and never arrives to the destination. We tried other open-source SMTP servers in the same configuration - they do not loop and deliver the mail to the next hop.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: server-dev-unsubscribe@james.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: server-dev-help@james.apache.org
[jira] Commented: (JAMES-1018) James SMTP server while redirecting
mail sends it to itself rather than to the destination
Posted by "Anastasia Tugaenko (JIRA)" <se...@james.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-1018?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=12890279#action_12890279 ]
Anastasia Tugaenko commented on JAMES-1018:
-------------------------------------------
The problem is that James server doesn't recognize that next translation will be to itself. So it sends mail to itself all allowed number of times. And also it doesn't send the notification about undeliverable of message to the originator.
> James SMTP server while redirecting mail sends it to itself rather than to the destination
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JAMES-1018
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-1018
> Project: JAMES Server
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SMTPServer
> Affects Versions: 2.3.1
> Environment: Windows XP
> Reporter: Anastasia Tugaenko
> Priority: Minor
>
> Under certain network and DNS configuration James SMTP server version 2.3.1 sends mail to itself rather than to the next hop. As a result, the mail loops until resending limit is exceeded. It never gets to the destination.
>
> Configuration
> The configuration file - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/config.xml.
> The issue was reproduced in a virtual network with three nodes and two domains (see http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/virtualNet.png):
> 1. network vbox1.test with nodes XP11 and XP12,
> 2. network vbox2.test with nodes XP21 and XP22;
> 3. nodes XP11 and XP21 are physically on the same virtual machine where James SMTP server runs. DNS runs on the same server.
> DNS configuration used to reproduces the issue is available here - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/etc.zip.
> The issue occurs when MX record for XP21 has higher priority than that of XP22.
> XP22 IN MX 15 XP21
> XP22 IN MX 25 XP22
> Steps to reproduce the issue:
> 1. Turn on the virtual machines for nodes XP11/XP21, XP12, XP22. Launch DNS and James SMTP on the XP11/XP21 virtual machine. Launch mail agents on XP12 and XP22.
> 2. Send a mail from XP12 to XP22 (e.g. to user@XP22.vbox2.test).
>
> Issue:
> Mail agent on XP12 sends the mail to the James SMTP server on XP11. The James SMTP server re-sends the mail to itself (the MX record priority is higher than that of XP22). As a result the mail never arrives to XP22.
> James SMTP log is available here - http://www.ispras.ru/ru/james/smtpserver.log.
> Here is an extract from it:
> 09/06/10 16:54:51 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP12 (192.168.56.22)
> 09/06/10 16:54:52 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088091716-0 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.56.22 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> 09/06/10 16:55:32 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
> 09/06/10 16:55:32 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088132675-1 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> 09/06/10 16:56:12 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
> 09/06/10 16:56:12 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088172782-2 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> 09/06/10 16:56:52 INFO smtpserver: Connection from XP1 (192.168.209.21)
> 09/06/10 16:56:52 INFO smtpserver: Successfully spooled mail Mail1276088212910-3 from asdfasdf@asd.a on 192.168.209.21 for [user@XP22.vbox2.test]
> The log shows that the mail gets constantly re-sent from XP11 to XP12 (the same physical machine) and never arrives to the destination. We tried other open-source SMTP servers in the same configuration - they do not loop and deliver the mail to the next hop.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: server-dev-unsubscribe@james.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: server-dev-help@james.apache.org