You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.

Posted to users@myfaces.apache.org by sandeep gururaj <sa...@Chordiant.com> on 2008/02/08 12:52:58 UTC

(Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

Hello All,

 

I have a form with 3 input fields and a command button. All 3 input
fields are mandatory (i.e required="true" is set). Now when I enter
values for all 3 input fields and click on the command button, I invoke
an action method that compares the values for the first 2 input fields.
If value of field-1 is not same as that of field-2, an error message
saying "Field-1 is not same as Field-2" is displayed on the UI;
otherwise, the 3 values are processed and a success message is
displayed.

 

Consider now that I enter 2 different values for field-1 and field-2 and
I also enter a value for field-3. When I click on the command button, I
get the error message as expected. Now, I will enter same value in
field-1 and field-2, but remove the entry from field-3. At this point,
when I click the command button, along with the old error message, I get
a new message saying "Field-3 is mandatory". I feel this is wrong
because my values in field-1 and field-2 are same now. So, I should only
get the new message for field-3.

 

I feel the cause for this issue is that when I click second time, the
check for field-1 and field-2 (which is in my backing bean) is not
happening and instead only the required field validation for field-3 is
happening.

 

I would like to know if there is any way to solve this problem.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

RE: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

Posted by sandeep gururaj <sa...@Chordiant.com>.

I would like to know if this issue can be raised in JIRA.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

 

________________________________

From: sandeep gururaj [mailto:sandeep.gururaj@chordiant.com] 
Sent: Monday, February 11, 2008 9:45 AM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: RE: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

 

I guess this is an issue in case we have a required field validation and
also an explicit check in the backing bean. Is there a way out?

 

~Sandeep

 

________________________________

From: sandeep gururaj [mailto:sandeep.gururaj@chordiant.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 08, 2008 6:19 PM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: RE: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

 

I just wanted to add that I am not sure if this is really an issue. If
Yes and if it can be solved, please let me know the same. If No, I would
like to know experiences from people who have observed such behavior.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

 

________________________________

From: sandeep gururaj [mailto:sandeep.gururaj@chordiant.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 08, 2008 5:23 PM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

 

Hello All,

 

I have a form with 3 input fields and a command button. All 3 input
fields are mandatory (i.e required="true" is set). Now when I enter
values for all 3 input fields and click on the command button, I invoke
an action method that compares the values for the first 2 input fields.
If value of field-1 is not same as that of field-2, an error message
saying "Field-1 is not same as Field-2" is displayed on the UI;
otherwise, the 3 values are processed and a success message is
displayed.

 

Consider now that I enter 2 different values for field-1 and field-2 and
I also enter a value for field-3. When I click on the command button, I
get the error message as expected. Now, I will enter same value in
field-1 and field-2, but remove the entry from field-3. At this point,
when I click the command button, along with the old error message, I get
a new message saying "Field-3 is mandatory". I feel this is wrong
because my values in field-1 and field-2 are same now. So, I should only
get the new message for field-3.

 

I feel the cause for this issue is that when I click second time, the
check for field-1 and field-2 (which is in my backing bean) is not
happening and instead only the required field validation for field-3 is
happening.

 

I would like to know if there is any way to solve this problem.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

RE: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

Posted by sandeep gururaj <sa...@Chordiant.com>.

I guess this is an issue in case we have a required field validation and
also an explicit check in the backing bean. Is there a way out?

 

~Sandeep

 

________________________________

From: sandeep gururaj [mailto:sandeep.gururaj@chordiant.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 08, 2008 6:19 PM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: RE: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

 

I just wanted to add that I am not sure if this is really an issue. If
Yes and if it can be solved, please let me know the same. If No, I would
like to know experiences from people who have observed such behavior.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

 

________________________________

From: sandeep gururaj [mailto:sandeep.gururaj@chordiant.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 08, 2008 5:23 PM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

 

Hello All,

 

I have a form with 3 input fields and a command button. All 3 input
fields are mandatory (i.e required="true" is set). Now when I enter
values for all 3 input fields and click on the command button, I invoke
an action method that compares the values for the first 2 input fields.
If value of field-1 is not same as that of field-2, an error message
saying "Field-1 is not same as Field-2" is displayed on the UI;
otherwise, the 3 values are processed and a success message is
displayed.

 

Consider now that I enter 2 different values for field-1 and field-2 and
I also enter a value for field-3. When I click on the command button, I
get the error message as expected. Now, I will enter same value in
field-1 and field-2, but remove the entry from field-3. At this point,
when I click the command button, along with the old error message, I get
a new message saying "Field-3 is mandatory". I feel this is wrong
because my values in field-1 and field-2 are same now. So, I should only
get the new message for field-3.

 

I feel the cause for this issue is that when I click second time, the
check for field-1 and field-2 (which is in my backing bean) is not
happening and instead only the required field validation for field-3 is
happening.

 

I would like to know if there is any way to solve this problem.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

RE: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

Posted by sandeep gururaj <sa...@Chordiant.com>.

I just wanted to add that I am not sure if this is really an issue. If
Yes and if it can be solved, please let me know the same. If No, I would
like to know experiences from people who have observed such behavior.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep

 

________________________________

From: sandeep gururaj [mailto:sandeep.gururaj@chordiant.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 08, 2008 5:23 PM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: (Trinidad) Refreshing error messages

 

Hello All,

 

I have a form with 3 input fields and a command button. All 3 input
fields are mandatory (i.e required="true" is set). Now when I enter
values for all 3 input fields and click on the command button, I invoke
an action method that compares the values for the first 2 input fields.
If value of field-1 is not same as that of field-2, an error message
saying "Field-1 is not same as Field-2" is displayed on the UI;
otherwise, the 3 values are processed and a success message is
displayed.

 

Consider now that I enter 2 different values for field-1 and field-2 and
I also enter a value for field-3. When I click on the command button, I
get the error message as expected. Now, I will enter same value in
field-1 and field-2, but remove the entry from field-3. At this point,
when I click the command button, along with the old error message, I get
a new message saying "Field-3 is mandatory". I feel this is wrong
because my values in field-1 and field-2 are same now. So, I should only
get the new message for field-3.

 

I feel the cause for this issue is that when I click second time, the
check for field-1 and field-2 (which is in my backing bean) is not
happening and instead only the required field validation for field-3 is
happening.

 

I would like to know if there is any way to solve this problem.

 

Thanks

~Sandeep