You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@cayenne.apache.org by Bill Dudney <bd...@apache.org> on 2006/08/07 05:36:51 UTC

TCK proposals

Hi All,

A couple of proposals on the handling of the TCK that I wanted to  
open a discussion on.

1) I feel strongly that we should limit access to the TCK to  
committers (as recommended here [1]). The ASF leaves it up to the PMC  
but I can't think of a good reason to let others have access to the TCK.

2) As I understand things we must keep the discussion of the TCK in  
private. I'd like to propose that we use the PPMC list (renamed to  
private recently) for those discussions.

Thoughts?

TTFN,

-bd-


[1]http://apache.org/jcp/


Re: TCK proposals

Posted by Mike Kienenberger <mk...@gmail.com>.
On 8/7/06, Bill Dudney <bd...@apache.org> wrote:
> >> 2) As I understand things we must keep the discussion of the TCK
> >> in private. I'd like to propose that we use the PPMC list (renamed
> >> to private recently) for those discussions.
> >
> > That means extending the PPMC subscription to all committers. Are
> > there any problems with that?
> >
>
> I personally would like eventually to have PMC == Committers. And I
> think we could/should be working towards that now as well. However
> that causes me to think that we should probably have a new mailing
> list for the tck, not archived and only available to subscribers.
>
> I just sent a mail to the open-jcp list asking if anyone decided on a
> naming scheme for these lists. I will keep you all posted.

Hey Bill,
We've talked about all of the TCK stuff before on MyFaces.   You must
have forgotten :)

To summarize:

1) The name would be tck@
2) The tck list needs to be separate from the pmc list (Some pmc
members may not be willing to sign the NDA, some TCK users may not be
PMC members).
3) Everything needs to go through Geir as the VP of JCP/TCK stuff.
4) Open an infra issue (INFRA-755 was the MyFaces one).

I'd also point out that this particular TCK is being used by several
projects and it'd make sense to share the list among them.

In fact, the tck@geronimo list might already be covering this TCK, and
the appropriate thing to do is to join their tck list.   Again, Geir
is the person to ask about that.

Re: TCK proposals

Posted by Bill Dudney <bd...@apache.org>.
On Aug 6, 2006, at 10:18 PM, Andrus Adamchik wrote:

> On Aug 6, 2006, at 11:36 PM, Bill Dudney wrote:
>> 1) I feel strongly that we should limit access to the TCK to  
>> committers (as recommended here [1]). The ASF leaves it up to the  
>> PMC but I can't think of a good reason to let others have access  
>> to the TCK.
>
> +1
>
>> 2) As I understand things we must keep the discussion of the TCK  
>> in private. I'd like to propose that we use the PPMC list (renamed  
>> to private recently) for those discussions.
>
> That means extending the PPMC subscription to all committers. Are  
> there any problems with that?
>

I personally would like eventually to have PMC == Committers. And I  
think we could/should be working towards that now as well. However  
that causes me to think that we should probably have a new mailing  
list for the tck, not archived and only available to subscribers.

I just sent a mail to the open-jcp list asking if anyone decided on a  
naming scheme for these lists. I will keep you all posted.

-bd-

> Andrus
>


Re: TCK proposals

Posted by Andrus Adamchik <an...@objectstyle.org>.
On Aug 6, 2006, at 11:36 PM, Bill Dudney wrote:
> 1) I feel strongly that we should limit access to the TCK to  
> committers (as recommended here [1]). The ASF leaves it up to the  
> PMC but I can't think of a good reason to let others have access to  
> the TCK.

+1

> 2) As I understand things we must keep the discussion of the TCK in  
> private. I'd like to propose that we use the PPMC list (renamed to  
> private recently) for those discussions.

That means extending the PPMC subscription to all committers. Are  
there any problems with that?

Andrus