You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@openoffice.apache.org by Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com> on 2013/12/16 12:47:47 UTC

[RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Hi,

we are still working on the 64 bit port which is intended to replace the
32 bit version in the future. We don't plan to support both because the
overhead is too much at the moment. And most used MacOS version are
already 64 bit and with the free available OS updates most systems are
running on a newer version anyway.

Nevertheless do we have to drop the support for 10.6 systems because of
a missing libc++ that was introduced on 10.7 first.

I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
the needs and requirements of many more users.


Juergen

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com>.
On 12/16/13 6:31 PM, Larry Gusaas wrote:
> On 2013-12-16, 5:47 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
>> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
>> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
>> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
>> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
>> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
>> the needs and requirements of many more users.
> -1
> There are a significant number of people who use 10.6 and won't upgrade
> for a variety of reasons.

we need real numbers. And we should keep in mind that Apple has a
different philosophy and cut older systems more rigorous. We have to
take this into account and the update on new core APIs was overdue. The
risk to run into real and bigger problems is very high.

If volunteers are interested to help here we can and will help but we
will focus on the mainstream and with supporting the last 3 versions I
believe we address most of the users.

Sorry if this sounds to harsh for you but we have to prioritize our work
and nobody should expect that we do all the work.

And believe me we don't drop an older version easy and we would prefer
to support as many as possible but sometimes the given constraints are
different.

And whatever reasons are there that don't allow a free update to a newer
system, these users should think if this platform is the right one for
them. Well this is just my personal opinion.

Juergen

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>.
On Tue, Dec 17, 2013 at 5:03 AM, Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 12/17/13 10:39 AM, Larry Gusaas wrote:
>> On 2013-12-17, 3:07 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
>>> On 12/16/13 6:31 PM, Larry Gusaas wrote:
>>>> On 2013-12-16, 5:47 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
>>>>> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
>>>>> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
>>>>> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
>>>>> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should
>>>>> take
>>>>> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
>>>>> the needs and requirements of many more users.
>>>> -1
>>>> There are a significant number of people who use 10.6 and won't upgrade
>>>> for a variety of reasons.
>>> we need real numbers. And we should keep in mind that Apple has a
>>> different philosophy and cut older systems more rigorous. We have to
>>> take this into account and the update on new core APIs was overdue. The
>>> risk to run into real and bigger problems is very high.
>>
>> 10.6 was replaced in July 2011. That is 2 year and 5 months ago.
>> You need real numbers to justify your position. I see lots of comments
>> from people on various support groups that they are not upgrading.
>>
>>> If volunteers are interested to help here we can and will help but we
>>> will focus on the mainstream and with supporting the last 3 versions I
>>> believe we address most of the users.
>>
>> Provide some valid statistics to back that up. You said you need real
>> numbers, provide them.
>
> I will try to provide download numbers and from which OS version these
> downloads are triggered
>

I have some data from Google Analytics, looking at people in the last
month who downloaded AOO for Mac.

10.9 is 57%
10.8 is 15%
10.7 is 9%
10.6 is 15%
10.5 is 3%
10.4 is <1%

Compare that to the numbers from 6 months ago (June 2013):

10.9 is N/A
10.8 is 45%
10.7 is 18%
10.6 is 22%
10.5 is 11%
10.4 is 3%

And Compare to 1 year ago (December 2012):

10.9 is N/A
10.8 is 34%
10.7 is 23%
10.6 is 31%
10.5 is 9%
10.4 is 3%


So it looks like 10.8 and 10.7 users have rapidly moved to 10.9.  10.6
users are dropping as well, but more slowly, from 31% to 15% in the
last 12 months.

Keep in mind that MacOS in total is around 10% of our users, so this
means that Mac OS 10.6 represents 1% or 2% of our total users.   Of
course, if the effort needed to support 10.6 was only 1% or 2%
incremental effort, over the dev effort for AOO 4.1, then I'd
recommend not dropping it.  But if it requires substantial effort to
preserve older compatibility, while also moving forward with 64-bit
support, then it is harder to justify diverting effort away from
deeper support for the majority of our users, for a much smaller
number of users lingering on 10.6.

I think it is interesting that other older OS's are well supported by
third parties, including Solaris and OS/2.  Maybe someone would be
interested in doing the same with older MacOS versions?

Regards,

-Rob

>>
>>> Sorry if this sounds to harsh for you but we have to prioritize our work
>>> and nobody should expect that we do all the work.
>>
>> What is this we/they thing. Is there two projects here? Sounds like
>> developer superiority speech to me.
>
> no we are one project but the work have to be done. I simply described
> that we will focus on the new clang environment and the upgrade to new
> core APIs to be able to run on future OS versions. We don't plan to
> focus on older systems. But I offered help if people think they need an
> older system and if they are interested to help. Because it comes not
> automatically.
>
>>
>>> And believe me we don't drop an older version easy and we would prefer
>>> to support as many as possible but sometimes the given constraints are
>>> different.
>>
>> A two year and five month old version is not old. After all, you still
>> support Windows XP.
>
> I agree but Apple follows a different approach than MS. You can blame
> Apple if you want. I described the technical reason for my initial
> proposal. I would prefer to continue the support of 10.6 but I see it
> also realistic.
>
>>
>>> And whatever reasons are there that don't allow a free update to a newer
>>> system, these users should think if this platform is the right one for
>>> them.
>>
>> There is no free upgrade from  OS X ver. 10.6, only paid upgrades.
>> The only free upgrade is to 10.9 and you require at least 10.7 to get
>> it. Many Intel Macs won't run 10.9.
>
> really, I thought it is possible to upgrade from 10.6.
>
> But anyway it is a lot of work to make the new env working with 10.6 and
> I don't see a chance to achieve this in time or at all if nobody is
> interested to help.
>
> Juergen
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org
>

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com>.
On 12/17/13 10:39 AM, Larry Gusaas wrote:
> On 2013-12-17, 3:07 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
>> On 12/16/13 6:31 PM, Larry Gusaas wrote:
>>> On 2013-12-16, 5:47 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
>>>> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
>>>> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
>>>> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
>>>> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should
>>>> take
>>>> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
>>>> the needs and requirements of many more users.
>>> -1
>>> There are a significant number of people who use 10.6 and won't upgrade
>>> for a variety of reasons.
>> we need real numbers. And we should keep in mind that Apple has a
>> different philosophy and cut older systems more rigorous. We have to
>> take this into account and the update on new core APIs was overdue. The
>> risk to run into real and bigger problems is very high.
> 
> 10.6 was replaced in July 2011. That is 2 year and 5 months ago.
> You need real numbers to justify your position. I see lots of comments
> from people on various support groups that they are not upgrading.
> 
>> If volunteers are interested to help here we can and will help but we
>> will focus on the mainstream and with supporting the last 3 versions I
>> believe we address most of the users.
> 
> Provide some valid statistics to back that up. You said you need real
> numbers, provide them.

I will try to provide download numbers and from which OS version these
downloads are triggered

> 
>> Sorry if this sounds to harsh for you but we have to prioritize our work
>> and nobody should expect that we do all the work.
> 
> What is this we/they thing. Is there two projects here? Sounds like
> developer superiority speech to me.

no we are one project but the work have to be done. I simply described
that we will focus on the new clang environment and the upgrade to new
core APIs to be able to run on future OS versions. We don't plan to
focus on older systems. But I offered help if people think they need an
older system and if they are interested to help. Because it comes not
automatically.

> 
>> And believe me we don't drop an older version easy and we would prefer
>> to support as many as possible but sometimes the given constraints are
>> different.
> 
> A two year and five month old version is not old. After all, you still
> support Windows XP.

I agree but Apple follows a different approach than MS. You can blame
Apple if you want. I described the technical reason for my initial
proposal. I would prefer to continue the support of 10.6 but I see it
also realistic.

> 
>> And whatever reasons are there that don't allow a free update to a newer
>> system, these users should think if this platform is the right one for
>> them.
> 
> There is no free upgrade from  OS X ver. 10.6, only paid upgrades.
> The only free upgrade is to 10.9 and you require at least 10.7 to get
> it. Many Intel Macs won't run 10.9.

really, I thought it is possible to upgrade from 10.6.

But anyway it is a lot of work to make the new env working with 10.6 and
I don't see a chance to achieve this in time or at all if nobody is
interested to help.

Juergen

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Larry Gusaas <la...@gmail.com>.
On 2013-12-17, 3:07 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
> On 12/16/13 6:31 PM, Larry Gusaas wrote:
>> On 2013-12-16, 5:47 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
>>> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
>>> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
>>> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
>>> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
>>> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
>>> the needs and requirements of many more users.
>> -1
>> There are a significant number of people who use 10.6 and won't upgrade
>> for a variety of reasons.
> we need real numbers. And we should keep in mind that Apple has a
> different philosophy and cut older systems more rigorous. We have to
> take this into account and the update on new core APIs was overdue. The
> risk to run into real and bigger problems is very high.

10.6 was replaced in July 2011. That is 2 year and 5 months ago.
You need real numbers to justify your position. I see lots of comments from people on various 
support groups that they are not upgrading.

> If volunteers are interested to help here we can and will help but we
> will focus on the mainstream and with supporting the last 3 versions I
> believe we address most of the users.

Provide some valid statistics to back that up. You said you need real numbers, provide them.

> Sorry if this sounds to harsh for you but we have to prioritize our work
> and nobody should expect that we do all the work.

What is this we/they thing. Is there two projects here? Sounds like developer superiority 
speech to me.

> And believe me we don't drop an older version easy and we would prefer
> to support as many as possible but sometimes the given constraints are
> different.

A two year and five month old version is not old. After all, you still support Windows XP.

> And whatever reasons are there that don't allow a free update to a newer
> system, these users should think if this platform is the right one for
> them.

There is no free upgrade from  OS X ver. 10.6, only paid upgrades.
The only free upgrade is to 10.9 and you require at least 10.7 to get it. Many Intel Macs won't 
run 10.9.

> Well this is just my personal opinion.
>
> Juergen


-- 
_________________________________

Larry I. Gusaas
Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan Canada
Website: http://larry-gusaas.com
"An artist is never ahead of his time but most people are far behind theirs." - Edgard Varese




---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Larry Gusaas <la...@gmail.com>.
On 2013-12-16, 5:47 AM Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
> the needs and requirements of many more users.
-1
There are a significant number of people who use 10.6 and won't upgrade for a variety of reasons.

-- 
_________________________________

Larry I. Gusaas
Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan Canada
Website: http://larry-gusaas.com
"An artist is never ahead of his time but most people are far behind theirs." - Edgard Varese




---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com>.
On 12/16/13 1:02 PM, Jürgen Schmidt wrote:
> On 12/16/13 12:55 PM, jan i wrote:
>> On 16 December 2013 12:47, Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> we are still working on the 64 bit port which is intended to replace the
>>> 32 bit version in the future. We don't plan to support both because the
>>> overhead is too much at the moment. And most used MacOS version are
>>> already 64 bit and with the free available OS updates most systems are
>>> running on a newer version anyway.
>>>
>>> Nevertheless do we have to drop the support for 10.6 systems because of
>>> a missing libc++ that was introduced on 10.7 first.
>>>
>>
>>> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
>>> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
>>> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
>>> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
>>> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
>>> the needs and requirements of many more users.
>>>
>> +1, I also expect that the upcomming macOs buildbot will only support one
>> MacOS version, and that should be the mainline.
> 
> it is not so easy and in general we would like to support as many as
> possible MacOS versions. The point is that we need the related platform
> SDK and our initial plan was to build against the 10.6 SDK.  But with
> the upgrade to Xcode 4 the 10.6 SDK is not supported anymore and you
> have to tweak your system which would be ok in general. We developed
> against 10.7 SDK and did some tests last week against the 10.6 SDK and
> realized that the libc++ was introduced with 10.7 first.
> 
> In general it is important that the used system APIs are still valid and
> supported by a platform. With the 64bit version Herbert replaced some
> deprecated APIs as well.

To avoid any confusion with AOO 4.1 we will add a MacOS version check.
For testing I checked against 10.8 and running on a 10.7 system. The
check will mark the OpenOffice.app as not useable and if somebody double
click on it a dialog pops up to give addtinal information.

See
http://people.apache.org/~jsc/screenshots/MacOS_version_check_AOO4.1.png
for a preview.

For AOO 4.1 we will check against 10.7.0

Juergen

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com>.
On 12/16/13 12:55 PM, jan i wrote:
> On 16 December 2013 12:47, Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com> wrote:
> 
>> Hi,
>>
>> we are still working on the 64 bit port which is intended to replace the
>> 32 bit version in the future. We don't plan to support both because the
>> overhead is too much at the moment. And most used MacOS version are
>> already 64 bit and with the free available OS updates most systems are
>> running on a newer version anyway.
>>
>> Nevertheless do we have to drop the support for 10.6 systems because of
>> a missing libc++ that was introduced on 10.7 first.
>>
> 
>> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
>> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
>> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
>> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
>> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
>> the needs and requirements of many more users.
>>
> +1, I also expect that the upcomming macOs buildbot will only support one
> MacOS version, and that should be the mainline.

it is not so easy and in general we would like to support as many as
possible MacOS versions. The point is that we need the related platform
SDK and our initial plan was to build against the 10.6 SDK.  But with
the upgrade to Xcode 4 the 10.6 SDK is not supported anymore and you
have to tweak your system which would be ok in general. We developed
against 10.7 SDK and did some tests last week against the 10.6 SDK and
realized that the libc++ was introduced with 10.7 first.

In general it is important that the used system APIs are still valid and
supported by a platform. With the 64bit version Herbert replaced some
deprecated APIs as well.

Juergen


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Re: [RELEASE]: new MacOS compiler used for the 64 bit tool chain requires a new baseline

Posted by jan i <ja...@apache.org>.
On 16 December 2013 12:47, Jürgen Schmidt <jo...@gmail.com> wrote:

> Hi,
>
> we are still working on the 64 bit port which is intended to replace the
> 32 bit version in the future. We don't plan to support both because the
> overhead is too much at the moment. And most used MacOS version are
> already 64 bit and with the free available OS updates most systems are
> running on a newer version anyway.
>
> Nevertheless do we have to drop the support for 10.6 systems because of
> a missing libc++ that was introduced on 10.7 first.
>

> I would like to propose that with AOO 4.1 we support 10.7 or higher
> MacOS systems only at the beginning. We can decide later on if it's
> worth to spend additional time in 10.6 systems but for now I would not
> spent any further time on it. We have to look forward and we should take
> into account that we have many other things to do that will be address
> the needs and requirements of many more users.
>
+1, I also expect that the upcomming macOs buildbot will only support one
MacOS version, and that should be the mainline.

rgds
jan I.

>
>
> Juergen
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org
>
>