You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to marketing@openoffice.apache.org by Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> on 2012/03/05 23:12:51 UTC
Alienating users
Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a marketing and communications one.
On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>
> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to the program they use.
This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is reality.
And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
> Office.
>
> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
> education.
I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any notices.
--Jean
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Barbara Parenti <ba...@gmail.com>.
* *> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause
(someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes
many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be
irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they
stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure
you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to
the program they use.
if it can be good for the discussion, I was in the pass an user,
unsympathetic or hostile to program I use, this in the pass, with many
programs! WHY? Because the programm often be too difficol for me to
understand, user guide was not sufficent and not so easy, and the most of
time need so many time to read guide , than do what you want to do with
program, this happend still today, also when you have learn well to use
the programs, because you have not decided to use but the most important
thing is that interface, menus and tools not so friendly and yet not
intuitive and difficult, this creates frustration in the user and then
disliked the program and the user is unsympatetic , I'm not talking about
open office in particular but in general, the fact that yet for the
end user everything
is too difficult.
I hope can need this personal experience
Sorry if engllish is not perfect
Barbara
2012/3/5 Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com>
> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a
> marketing and communications one.
>
> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> >
> > I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
> > users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>
> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause
> (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes
> many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be
> irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they
> stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure
> you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to
> the program they use.
>
> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is
> reality.
>
> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will
> gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of
> whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is
> in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the
> world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>
> > Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
> > reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
> > share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
> > compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
> > the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
> > checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
> > hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
> > But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
> > OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
> > what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
> > Office.
> >
> > A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
> > world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
> > education.
>
> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before
> they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given
> that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any
> notices.
>
> --Jean
>
--
*BABECOON MAINE COON CATTERY*
* ALLEVAMENTO DI GATTI DI RAZZA MAINE COON con Affisso Anfi/ Fife*
* DI BARBARA PARENTI*
*ROMA ITALY*
*phone + 39 329 3358823*
*+39 06 5021220*
*http://www.babecoon.it*
*http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002063939027*
* http://www.babecoon. <http://www.babecoon.it>com*
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Terry <te...@yahoo.com.au>.
----- Original Message -----
> From: Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>
> To: ooo-marketing@incubator.apache.org
> Cc:
> Sent: Tuesday, 6 March 2012 9:26 AM
> Subject: Re: Alienating users
>
> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a
> marketing and communications one.
>>
>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>>>
>>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
>>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>>
>> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean
> "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User
> inconvenience causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may,
> or may not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact
> that they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated.
> I'm sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic
> or hostile" to the program they use.
>>
>> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is reality.
>>
>> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will
>> gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of whether
>> it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is
>> in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the world,
>> either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>>
>>><snip>
>>> And what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
>>> Office.
>>>
>>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
>>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
>>> education.
>>
>> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before
> they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given
> that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any notices.
>>
The simplest way of reaching users is to place a notice on the download pages.
>
> And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
> destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
> The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
> related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
> reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
> seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
>
Having to reinstall extensions is bad news. It is worse if people find out the hard way that it is necessary. People should be told about that need *before* they update. README files are not drawn to a user's attention and, in any case, become available after downloading and installing.
The negative impact of known issues can be attenuated by a prominent notice on the download pages.
> <snip>
>
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Wolf Halton <wo...@gmail.com>.
Seems like a good idea to have "known issue" notice on the download page.
http://sourcefreedom.com
On Mar 6, 2012 7:00 PM, "Terry" <te...@yahoo.com.au> wrote:
> What would be so terrible as placing a notice on download pages?
>
>
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> > From: Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>
> > To: ooo-marketing@incubator.apache.org
> > Cc:
> > Sent: Wednesday, 7 March 2012 2:32 AM
> > Subject: Re: Alienating users
> >
> > On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 9:13 AM, richard clary <r....@gmail.com>
> wrote:
> >> Pick up the phone, use some marketing money to set a conference
> bridge, or
> >> better yet, this is as good some face-book "threads" gets do
> > that, there
> >> would be no cause for public un-awareness then.
> >>
> >
> > Yes, this is not rocket science. For example, the move from Symphony
> > 1.3 to 3.0 also introduced incompatibility with all extensions, so
> > they all needed to be reinstalled by the user. Symphony 3.0 then went
> > on to win PC Magazine's "Editor's Choice" award.
> >
> > There is a self-fulfilling prophecy aspect to marketing. If we sit
> > and whine about how bad things are, then users will just hear about
> > our whining and they will feel alienated. If instead we focus on the
> > good things and promote that, then they will be more forgiving of a
> > 1-time install inconvenience.
> >
> > -Rob
> >
> >><snip>
>
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Terry <te...@yahoo.com.au>.
What would be so terrible as placing a notice on download pages?
----- Original Message -----
> From: Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>
> To: ooo-marketing@incubator.apache.org
> Cc:
> Sent: Wednesday, 7 March 2012 2:32 AM
> Subject: Re: Alienating users
>
> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 9:13 AM, richard clary <r....@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Pick up the phone, use some marketing money to set a conference bridge, or
>> better yet, this is as good some face-book "threads" gets do
> that, there
>> would be no cause for public un-awareness then.
>>
>
> Yes, this is not rocket science. For example, the move from Symphony
> 1.3 to 3.0 also introduced incompatibility with all extensions, so
> they all needed to be reinstalled by the user. Symphony 3.0 then went
> on to win PC Magazine's "Editor's Choice" award.
>
> There is a self-fulfilling prophecy aspect to marketing. If we sit
> and whine about how bad things are, then users will just hear about
> our whining and they will feel alienated. If instead we focus on the
> good things and promote that, then they will be more forgiving of a
> 1-time install inconvenience.
>
> -Rob
>
>><snip>
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>.
On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 9:13 AM, richard clary <r....@gmail.com> wrote:
> Pick up the phone, use some marketing money to set a conference bridge, or
> better yet, this is as good some face-book "threads" gets do that, there
> would be no cause for public un-awareness then.
>
Yes, this is not rocket science. For example, the move from Symphony
1.3 to 3.0 also introduced incompatibility with all extensions, so
they all needed to be reinstalled by the user. Symphony 3.0 then went
on to win PC Magazine's "Editor's Choice" award.
There is a self-fulfilling prophecy aspect to marketing. If we sit
and whine about how bad things are, then users will just hear about
our whining and they will feel alienated. If instead we focus on the
good things and promote that, then they will be more forgiving of a
1-time install inconvenience.
-Rob
> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:57 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 11:33, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>> > On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 7:17 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> >> On 06/03/2012, at 8:26, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>> >>
>> >>> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com>
>> wrote:
>> >>>> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up
>> being a marketing and communications one.
>> >>>>
>> >>>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>> >>>>>
>> >>>>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
>> >>>>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>> >>>>
>> >>>> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean
>> "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience
>> causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may
>> not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that
>> they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm
>> sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or
>> hostile" to the program they use.
>> >>>>
>> >>>> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it
>> is reality.
>> >>>>
>> >>>> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media
>> will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless
>> of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it
>> is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the
>> world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>> >>>>
>> >>>>> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
>> >>>>> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
>> >>>>> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
>> >>>>> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
>> >>>>> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
>> >>>>> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
>> >>>>> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
>> >>>>> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
>> >>>>> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
>> >>>>> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
>> >>>>> Office.
>> >>>>>
>> >>>>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
>> >>>>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
>> >>>>> education.
>> >>>>
>> >>>> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably
>> before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that,
>> given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any
>> notices.
>> >>>>
>> >>>
>> >>> And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
>> >>> destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
>> >>> The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
>> >>> related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
>> >>> reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
>> >>> seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
>> >>>
>> >>> -Rob
>> >>
>> >> Speaking of alienation, Rob, your habit of seizing upon some poorly
>> worded phrase and proceeding to deliberately misunderstand or misconstrue
>> it and then both change the subject and insult the writer is rather
>> alienating -- or al least demotivating -- to other team members. That may
>> have won you points in college debates, but it's a very poor way to work in
>> a team. I can deal with that sort of nonsense, but I really have better
>> things to do with my time.
>> >>
>> >
>> > Jean, if you have a bug then please report it in BZ. That is where
>> > bugs belong. That is what we are using to prioritize bugs. That is
>> > the specific procedure we've agreed on for requesting and approving
>> > 3.4 release blocking issues. I don't think this is an unreasonable
>> > request.
>> >
>> > However, if you do not actually do not have such a bug, then feel free
>> > to complain about me instead, for whatever satisfaction that brings
>> > you. Actually it does not even need to be an either/or thing. You can
>> > report an issue in BZ and complain about me as well if that floats
>> > your boat. My sole concern is to ascertain whether you actually have
>> > an issue to report.
>> >
>> > Regards,
>> >
>> > -Rob
>>
>> My point is the necessity to communicate clearly, and early, to users
>> about a situation they are going to encounter. On the original thread
>> you finally gave a plain-English explanation to clear up
>> misconceptions. Had you done that earlier, instead of sniping at me
>> and Dennis and Larry and treating us like adversaries rather than
>> members of the team, it would have been helpful and avoided a lot of
>> wasted time, much of it yours.
>>
>> --Jean
>>
>
>
>
> --
> Richard (Rrickey) Clary
> Sr. Analyst Product Introduction (Retired)
Re: Alienating users
Posted by richard clary <r....@gmail.com>.
Pick up the phone, use some marketing money to set a conference bridge, or
better yet, this is as good some face-book "threads" gets do that, there
would be no cause for public un-awareness then.
On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:57 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 11:33, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> > On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 7:17 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
> >> On 06/03/2012, at 8:26, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> >>
> >>> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com>
> wrote:
> >>>> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up
> being a marketing and communications one.
> >>>>
> >>>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> >>>>>
> >>>>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
> >>>>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
> >>>>
> >>>> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean
> "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience
> causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may
> not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that
> they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm
> sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or
> hostile" to the program they use.
> >>>>
> >>>> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it
> is reality.
> >>>>
> >>>> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media
> will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless
> of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it
> is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the
> world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
> >>>>
> >>>>> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
> >>>>> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
> >>>>> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
> >>>>> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
> >>>>> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
> >>>>> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
> >>>>> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
> >>>>> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
> >>>>> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
> >>>>> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
> >>>>> Office.
> >>>>>
> >>>>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
> >>>>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
> >>>>> education.
> >>>>
> >>>> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably
> before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that,
> given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any
> notices.
> >>>>
> >>>
> >>> And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
> >>> destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
> >>> The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
> >>> related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
> >>> reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
> >>> seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
> >>>
> >>> -Rob
> >>
> >> Speaking of alienation, Rob, your habit of seizing upon some poorly
> worded phrase and proceeding to deliberately misunderstand or misconstrue
> it and then both change the subject and insult the writer is rather
> alienating -- or al least demotivating -- to other team members. That may
> have won you points in college debates, but it's a very poor way to work in
> a team. I can deal with that sort of nonsense, but I really have better
> things to do with my time.
> >>
> >
> > Jean, if you have a bug then please report it in BZ. That is where
> > bugs belong. That is what we are using to prioritize bugs. That is
> > the specific procedure we've agreed on for requesting and approving
> > 3.4 release blocking issues. I don't think this is an unreasonable
> > request.
> >
> > However, if you do not actually do not have such a bug, then feel free
> > to complain about me instead, for whatever satisfaction that brings
> > you. Actually it does not even need to be an either/or thing. You can
> > report an issue in BZ and complain about me as well if that floats
> > your boat. My sole concern is to ascertain whether you actually have
> > an issue to report.
> >
> > Regards,
> >
> > -Rob
>
> My point is the necessity to communicate clearly, and early, to users
> about a situation they are going to encounter. On the original thread
> you finally gave a plain-English explanation to clear up
> misconceptions. Had you done that earlier, instead of sniping at me
> and Dennis and Larry and treating us like adversaries rather than
> members of the team, it would have been helpful and avoided a lot of
> wasted time, much of it yours.
>
> --Jean
>
--
Richard (Rrickey) Clary
Sr. Analyst Product Introduction (Retired)
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com>.
On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 11:33, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 7:17 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> On 06/03/2012, at 8:26, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>>
>>> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>>> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a marketing and communications one.
>>>>
>>>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
>>>>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>>>>
>>>> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to the program they use.
>>>>
>>>> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is reality.
>>>>
>>>> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>>>>
>>>>> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
>>>>> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
>>>>> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
>>>>> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
>>>>> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
>>>>> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
>>>>> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
>>>>> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
>>>>> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
>>>>> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
>>>>> Office.
>>>>>
>>>>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
>>>>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
>>>>> education.
>>>>
>>>> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any notices.
>>>>
>>>
>>> And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
>>> destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
>>> The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
>>> related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
>>> reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
>>> seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
>>>
>>> -Rob
>>
>> Speaking of alienation, Rob, your habit of seizing upon some poorly worded phrase and proceeding to deliberately misunderstand or misconstrue it and then both change the subject and insult the writer is rather alienating -- or al least demotivating -- to other team members. That may have won you points in college debates, but it's a very poor way to work in a team. I can deal with that sort of nonsense, but I really have better things to do with my time.
>>
>
> Jean, if you have a bug then please report it in BZ. That is where
> bugs belong. That is what we are using to prioritize bugs. That is
> the specific procedure we've agreed on for requesting and approving
> 3.4 release blocking issues. I don't think this is an unreasonable
> request.
>
> However, if you do not actually do not have such a bug, then feel free
> to complain about me instead, for whatever satisfaction that brings
> you. Actually it does not even need to be an either/or thing. You can
> report an issue in BZ and complain about me as well if that floats
> your boat. My sole concern is to ascertain whether you actually have
> an issue to report.
>
> Regards,
>
> -Rob
My point is the necessity to communicate clearly, and early, to users
about a situation they are going to encounter. On the original thread
you finally gave a plain-English explanation to clear up
misconceptions. Had you done that earlier, instead of sniping at me
and Dennis and Larry and treating us like adversaries rather than
members of the team, it would have been helpful and avoided a lot of
wasted time, much of it yours.
--Jean
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>.
On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 7:17 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 06/03/2012, at 8:26, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>
>> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a marketing and communications one.
>>>
>>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
>>>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>>>
>>> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to the program they use.
>>>
>>> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is reality.
>>>
>>> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>>>
>>>> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
>>>> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
>>>> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
>>>> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
>>>> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
>>>> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
>>>> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
>>>> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
>>>> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
>>>> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
>>>> Office.
>>>>
>>>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
>>>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
>>>> education.
>>>
>>> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any notices.
>>>
>>
>> And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
>> destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
>> The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
>> related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
>> reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
>> seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
>>
>> -Rob
>
> Speaking of alienation, Rob, your habit of seizing upon some poorly worded phrase and proceeding to deliberately misunderstand or misconstrue it and then both change the subject and insult the writer is rather alienating -- or al least demotivating -- to other team members. That may have won you points in college debates, but it's a very poor way to work in a team. I can deal with that sort of nonsense, but I really have better things to do with my time.
>
Jean, if you have a bug then please report it in BZ. That is where
bugs belong. That is what we are using to prioritize bugs. That is
the specific procedure we've agreed on for requesting and approving
3.4 release blocking issues. I don't think this is an unreasonable
request.
However, if you do not actually do not have such a bug, then feel free
to complain about me instead, for whatever satisfaction that brings
you. Actually it does not even need to be an either/or thing. You can
report an issue in BZ and complain about me as well if that floats
your boat. My sole concern is to ascertain whether you actually have
an issue to report.
Regards,
-Rob
> --Jean
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com>.
On 06/03/2012, at 8:26, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a marketing and communications one.
>>
>> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>>>
>>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
>>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>>
>> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to the program they use.
>>
>> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is reality.
>>
>> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>>
>>> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
>>> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
>>> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
>>> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
>>> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
>>> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
>>> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
>>> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
>>> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
>>> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
>>> Office.
>>>
>>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
>>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
>>> education.
>>
>> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any notices.
>>
>
> And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
> destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
> The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
> related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
> reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
> seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
>
> -Rob
Speaking of alienation, Rob, your habit of seizing upon some poorly worded phrase and proceeding to deliberately misunderstand or misconstrue it and then both change the subject and insult the writer is rather alienating -- or al least demotivating -- to other team members. That may have won you points in college debates, but it's a very poor way to work in a team. I can deal with that sort of nonsense, but I really have better things to do with my time.
--Jean
Re: Alienating users
Posted by Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>.
On Mon, Mar 5, 2012 at 5:12 PM, Jean Weber <je...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Moving this to Marketing, because I think the problem will end up being a marketing and communications one.
>
> On Tue, Mar 6, 2012 at 06:36, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
>>
>> I don't equate any amount of user inconvenience with "alienating
>> users." To suggest this is pure hyperbole, divorced from reality.
>
> Perhaps we use the term "alienate" differently. I used it to mean "Cause (someone) to become unsympathetic or hostile." User inconvenience causes many people to become unsympathetic or hostile. They may, or may not, be irritated enough to switch to an alternative program. The fact that they stay with a program they hate doesn't mean they are not alienated. I'm sure you are aware of how many MS Office users are "unsympathetic or hostile" to the program they use.
>
> This observation is not "pure hyperbole, divorced from reality" -- it is reality.
>
> And you should know perfectly well that some sectors of the media will gleefully seize upon the issue as a major failure of AOO, regardless of whether it's "business as usual" for other software and even though it is in fact a relatively minor issue. Bad publicity is not the end of the world, either, but it's not going to help us, and we need to be prepared.
>
>> Microsoft breaks their plugins with every release and requires
>> reinstall. They seem to manage to preserve a non-negligible market
>> share. Many programs do this. Some do better, some check for
>> compatibility and enable some but not all extensions. I suppose if
>> the Mozilla developers said that they had to bread the compatibility
>> checking code in a release, that some project members might resort to
>> hyperbole about alienating users and say that it was unacceptable.
>> But not that their unacceptable solution is just life as usual for
>> OpenOffice, since we don't do compatibility checks on upgrade. And
>> what you call unacceptable in OpenOffice is just life as usual for MS
>> Office.
>>
>> A little perspective goes a long way. This is not the end of the
>> world. Not even close. I recommend dealing with it with user
>> education.
>
> I hope the user education actually reaches the users, preferably before they find their setup destroyed. I don't know how to best do that, given that most of our users are unlikely to see (or pay attention to) any notices.
>
And there you go again with the hyperbole. What setup is being
destroyed? I am not aware of any plan to wipe out the user's profile.
The only issue I know of is the inability of AOO 3.4 to read data
related to installed extensions. Such extensions will need to be
reinstalled. But your other preferences and settings, where have you
seen that they will be lost? Can you point me to a BZ issue?
-Rob
> --Jean