Duplicate Labels

[Vikas Mayur <vi...@gmail.com>]

I see that few labels (same) are spread over more than one *
UiLabels.properties file. I know there has been a good effort in cleaning
them day by day.
Though my question is little different.
Say, I have a label already defined in ManufacturingUiLabel.properties and I
need that in accounitng or any other component.
What is wise to do ?
1) Either to use this label.
    AFAIK that we check the label in some priority like we start from
CommonUi if it is found there, it is preferred over if it is found in any
other component (because of duplicacy)
2) Create a same label for accounting component as well, but that will add
to duplicacy.

I am confused with this issue. Can any one help me out ?

Thanks,
- Vikas

Re: Duplicate Labels

[David E Jones <jo...@hotwaxmedia.com>]

The intended pattern is a little more complex, but not much:

1. put labels in the most natural/applicable component; if another  
component needs that label, and it clearly belongs in the first then  
the properties file from the first should be used from the second

2. for labels used in lots of components, and for common words and  
phrases, put them in the common component and include/use in other  
components

-David


On Jan 12, 2008, at 7:43 PM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:

> Quick answer,
>
> I think we should put in common all labels used in more than one  
> component. It's the only way to keep things simple. But maybe I'm  
> missing something because this is so obvious.
>
> Jacques
>
> From: "Vikas Mayur" <vi...@gmail.com>
>> I see that few labels (same) are spread over more than one *
>> UiLabels.properties file. I know there has been a good effort in  
>> cleaning
>> them day by day.
>> Though my question is little different.
>> Say, I have a label already defined in  
>> ManufacturingUiLabel.properties and I
>> need that in accounitng or any other component.
>> What is wise to do ?
>> 1) Either to use this label.
>>   AFAIK that we check the label in some priority like we start from
>> CommonUi if it is found there, it is preferred over if it is found  
>> in any
>> other component (because of duplicacy)
>> 2) Create a same label for accounting component as well, but that  
>> will add
>> to duplicacy.
>>
>> I am confused with this issue. Can any one help me out ?
>>
>> Thanks,
>> - Vikas
>

Re: Duplicate Labels

[Jacques Le Roux <ja...@les7arts.com>]

Quick answer,

I think we should put in common all labels used in more than one component. It's the only way to keep things simple. But maybe I'm 
missing something because this is so obvious.

Jacques

From: "Vikas Mayur" <vi...@gmail.com>
>I see that few labels (same) are spread over more than one *
> UiLabels.properties file. I know there has been a good effort in cleaning
> them day by day.
> Though my question is little different.
> Say, I have a label already defined in ManufacturingUiLabel.properties and I
> need that in accounitng or any other component.
> What is wise to do ?
> 1) Either to use this label.
>    AFAIK that we check the label in some priority like we start from
> CommonUi if it is found there, it is preferred over if it is found in any
> other component (because of duplicacy)
> 2) Create a same label for accounting component as well, but that will add
> to duplicacy.
>
> I am confused with this issue. Can any one help me out ?
>
> Thanks,
> - Vikas
>