You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@roller.apache.org by William Tribley <bi...@tribley.org> on 2006/08/16 05:45:45 UTC

Got a License, Buddy?

This sounds like a real shame. No one is even getting rich, and  
Roller developers have to refactor and rethink b/c of a licensing  
issue. M$ and the pay software crowd wins all of these disputes,  
whatever is decided, because in the end our software becomes more and  
more mediocre and complex, encouraging people to part with money to  
get code with lots of features that is simple and works.

Roller developers should be able to concentrate on features, not on  
writing multiple backends. The real kicker comes at install time: Joe  
Sysadmin, who has average aptitude and no patience, installs Roller  
and it breaks out of the box because he forgot to go get the backend  
of his choice (and he knows not enough to choose, he just wants a  
blog site...) from some other developer site somewhere. Tech support  
requests multiply, the perception spreads slowly that Roller is hard  
to install out of the box, you know how it goes!


On Aug 15, 2006, at 10:11 PM, paksegu wrote:

> Two Issues facing Roller
>
>
>    A large Roller Customer who prefers Hibernate.
>    The need to satisfy Apache Software license requirement for it  
> to remain an Apache project. Implementation can be either JDO or JPA.
>
>   It may see logical to implement both solutions by letting  
> Customers and Developers who prefer Hibernate to continue to do so  
> and distribute the Hibernate version via www.Java.net, and  
> developers feeling the need to satisfy Apache Software requirements  
> choose either JDO or JPA to implement. This will seem an extra work  
> but it will be great for Roller if everyone if free to implement  
> their form of persistent technology.
>
>
>
>
> Matt Raible <mr...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>   On 8/15/06, Allen Gilliland wrote:
>>
>> assuming we agree that we are only focusing on implementing one of  
>> the
>> options, we then need to decide which one. just so it's known, i  
>> think
>> it's entirely lame that we are getting rid of Hibernate over a silly
>> licensing issue. as a large roller customer i consider it more of a
>> pain than a benefit to have to replace the backend. regardless of  
>> that
>> fact, it appears that's what everyone wants to do, so i consider
>> Hibernate to no longer be an option. that leaves JDO and JPA as you
>> mentioned, and i don't really have any preference between the two.
>
> I don't believe that "everyone wants to do so" is an accurate
> statement. I believe "Apache wants us to do so" is an accurate
> statement. I'd rather stick with Hibernate b/c it's been proven to
> work and I know it well. Remember all the issues we used to
> experience on JRoller? I'd hate to see any of those come back again.
>
> Matt