You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@openoffice.apache.org by Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com> on 2012/06/06 13:24:27 UTC

Tolerance and acceptance

I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
posts that are anti-LO on our lists.

For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:

"The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
support).

In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
.org)."

I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
let's unite around that."

Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
the ooo-users list.

Ross

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Albino B Neto <bi...@gmail.com>.
Hi.

2012/6/6 Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com>:
> I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
> LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
> own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
> posts that are anti-LO on our lists.
>
> For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:
>
> "The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
> following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
> OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
> support).
>
> In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
> StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
> .org)."
>
> I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
> opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
> they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
> goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
> let's unite around that."
>
> Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
> unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
> onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
> and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
> sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
> the ooo-users list.

+1

Albino

> Ross

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Kay Schenk <ka...@gmail.com>.
On Wed, Jun 6, 2012 at 4:24 AM, Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com>wrote:

> I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
> LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
> own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
> posts that are anti-LO on our lists.
>
> For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:
>
> "The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
> following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
> OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
> support).
>
> In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
> StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
> .org)."
>
> I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
> opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
> they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
> goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
> let's unite around that."
>
> Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
> unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
> onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
> and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
> sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
> the ooo-users list.
>
> Ross
>

+1

It's kind of surprising that this would show up on ooo-users

-- 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MzK

"Everything will be all right in the end...
      if it's not all right then it's not the end. "
             -- Sonny, "The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel"

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com>.
On 6 June 2012 12:24, Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com> wrote:
> I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
> opinions, regardless of their validity.

Thank you to the kind soul who pointed out how easy it is to offend in
these sensitive matters. The above should have said "regardless of
their validity or otherwise" ;-)

Ross

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Kevin Grignon <ke...@gmail.com>.
KG01 -  see comments inline

On Wednesday, June 6, 2012, Rob Weir wrote:

> On Wed, Jun 6, 2012 at 7:24 AM, Ross Gardler <rgardler@opendirective.com<javascript:;>>
> wrote:
> > I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
> > LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
> > own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
> > posts that are anti-LO on our lists.
> >
>
> And what about negative posts about AOO?  Shoul we "silence" those?  I
> hope not.  Negative posts from users (within some bounds of decorum)
> is valuable feedback to the project.  I think we should value frank
> discourse about the product and where it falls short.


KG01 - Agreed. No wrong answers. Both positive and negative feedback help
us understand if we are meeting our user's expectations.

>
> I don't think we expect users to be familiar with The Apache Way or
> even mailing lists in general.  We see all sorts of disorderly conduct
> on ooo-users, from SCREAMING ALL CAPS, to flames, etc.  Project
> members, on the other hand, should lead by example, and focus on
> constructive comments.


KG01 - Agreed. Take the high road, acknowledge input, and lead by example.


> So although I agree with your sentiment here, I think we need to be
> very careful when considering "silencing inflammatory posts" in
> general, since a ham fisted approach would also silence criticism of
> AOO, which is valuable to receive.
>
> -Rob
>
>
> > For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:
> >
> > "The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
> > following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
> > OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
> > support).
> >
> > In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
> > StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
> > .org)."
> >
> > I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
> > opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
> > they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
> > goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
> > let's unite around that."
> >
> > Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
> > unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
> > onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
> > and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
> > sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
> > the ooo-users list.
> >
> > Ross
>

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
On 6 June 2012 13:13, Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com> wrote:

>  PPMC who agree with me to consider
> sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
> the ooo-users list."
>

+1 let's be the ones acting like grown ups.


> Ross
>

-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com>.
On 6 June 2012 13:06, Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org> wrote:
> On Wed, Jun 6, 2012 at 7:24 AM, Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com> wrote:
>> I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
>> LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
>> own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
>> posts that are anti-LO on our lists.
>>
>
> And what about negative posts about AOO?  Shoul we "silence" those?  I
> hope not.  Negative posts from users (within some bounds of decorum)
> is valuable feedback to the project.  I think we should value frank
> discourse about the product and where it falls short.

I think it is pretty clear that I'm not talking about valuable
discussion. I'm talking about unnecessary inflammatory remarks which
contribute nothing or, worse, are detrimental.

> Project
> members, on the other hand, should lead by example, and focus on
> constructive comments.

+1

> So although I agree with your sentiment here, I think we need to be
> very careful when considering "silencing inflammatory posts" in
> general, since a ham fisted approach would also silence criticism of
> AOO, which is valuable to receive.

OK, my initial language makes it sound like I'm saying that we should
tell people to shut up. That was a poor choice of words on my part.
Instead why lets focus on the actual action I'm advocating:

"I'm not suggesting this be tackled
onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
the ooo-users list."

Ross

>
> -Rob
>
>
>> For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:
>>
>> "The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
>> following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
>> OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
>> support).
>>
>> In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
>> StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
>> .org)."
>>
>> I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
>> opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
>> they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
>> goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
>> let's unite around that."
>>
>> Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
>> unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
>> onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
>> and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
>> sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
>> the ooo-users list.
>>
>> Ross



-- 
Ross Gardler (@rgardler)
Programme Leader (Open Development)
OpenDirective http://opendirective.com

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>.
On Wed, Jun 6, 2012 at 7:24 AM, Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com> wrote:
> I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
> LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
> own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
> posts that are anti-LO on our lists.
>

And what about negative posts about AOO?  Shoul we "silence" those?  I
hope not.  Negative posts from users (within some bounds of decorum)
is valuable feedback to the project.  I think we should value frank
discourse about the product and where it falls short.

I don't think we expect users to be familiar with The Apache Way or
even mailing lists in general.  We see all sorts of disorderly conduct
on ooo-users, from SCREAMING ALL CAPS, to flames, etc.  Project
members, on the other hand, should lead by example, and focus on
constructive comments.

So although I agree with your sentiment here, I think we need to be
very careful when considering "silencing inflammatory posts" in
general, since a ham fisted approach would also silence criticism of
AOO, which is valuable to receive.

-Rob


> For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:
>
> "The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
> following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
> OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
> support).
>
> In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
> StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
> .org)."
>
> I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
> opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
> they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
> goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
> let's unite around that."
>
> Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
> unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
> onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
> and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
> sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
> the ooo-users list.
>
> Ross

Re: Tolerance and acceptance

Posted by Paulo de Souza Lima <pa...@varekai.org>.
+1000

2012/6/6 Ross Gardler <rg...@opendirective.com>

> I move that there is no need to continue to fuel the fires of AOO vs
> LO. The PPMC is now effective at ignoring anti-AOO materials on our
> own lists. I suggest the PPMC should further silence inflammatory
> posts that are anti-LO on our lists.
>
> For example, a recent post on ooo-users said:
>
> "The LO guys should have thought about that before forking OpenOffice
> following Novell's siren's call. (remember the first major fork of
> OpenOffice was Novell's Go-OO which incorporated the MS OOXML
> support).
>
> In fact, it was their actions that killed the commercial prospects of
> StarOffice, which Oracle had renamed "Oracle Open Office" (without the
> .org)."
>
> I suggest that the ooo-users list is not the place for these kinds of
> opinions, regardless of their validity. This is especially true when
> they are made in response to a positive comment, which was "The main
> goal has always been to create the best Office suite possible - so
> let's unite around that."
>
> Our communities need to be welcoming. There is no chance of creating
> unity if disunity is the response. I'm not suggesting this be tackled
> onlist, that can be counter-productive too. I'm merely highlighting it
> and encouraging individuals on the PPMC who agree with me to consider
> sending a polite but firm request to stay focused on helping users on
> the ooo-users list.
>
> Ross
>



-- 
Paulo de Souza Lima
http://almalivre.wordpress.com
Curitiba - PR
Linux User #432358
Ubuntu User #28729